Distillation Technology: What’s Next?

August
,
2019

Distillation is often described as a mature technology that is well understood and established, no longer requiring funding or attention from research and development. This thinking is flawed, as distillation has come a long way in the past three decades and has even more room to grow.

Distillation is considered by many to be a mature technology. As a result, large research institutes overlook its funding, and little research is done to advance the field. But, what does it mean for a technology to be mature?

Distillation is a mass-transfer process, regulated by thermodynamics, and subject to the laws of physics. While we understand the fundamentals of the operation, even after several decades of research, descriptive models of distillation that are exclusively based on first principles (without empirical fits) are not available. We still largely rely on testing and empirical observations to develop and describe distillation. And, we do not know what development may be around the next corner. Even small developments can result in large economic and sustainability improvements, as distillation is prevalent in the chemical process industries (CPI) globally.

Defining a technology as mature should not be based on an understanding of the principles that govern its operation. A technology’s maturity should be based on how much further progress can be made and what remains to be learned. Distillation, by this definition, is not mature and still has plenty of room to advance.

In the past three decades, distillation has advanced in:

  • thermodynamics and thermodynamic efficiency
  • process configurations
  • process simulations
  • process control
  • column internal design
  • column peripherals (e.g., heat transfer)
  • reliability and availability
  • operation in harsh environments
  • diagnostics.

Table 1 provides some specific examples of advancements in the past decade or so that have had a significant economic impact. Most of these have been enabled by research and development (R&D) supported by industry, either internally or through research consortia.

Table 1. These distillation technologies were all in the research phase in the 1990s and are now implemented in industry. The economic impact column is a subjective assessment of the benefits of the technology to industry.
Technology Current Status Impacted Operations Economic Impact
Electrolyte Modeling Used Extensively Refining, Chemicals, Waste Very High
Dividing-Wall Column Used Frequently Refining, Chemicals Medium
Reactive Distillation and Enhanced Distillation Used Frequently Refining, Chemicals Very High
Hybrid Processes (Distillation/Membranes/Adsorption) High Potential Gas Very High
Rate-Based Simulation Used Frequently All Medium
Hardware Performance Modeling Used Extensively All Very High
Model-Based and Adaptive Control Used Frequently Refining, Chemicals Medium
High-Capacity Trays Used Extensively All Very High
High-Capacity Packings Used Extensively All Very High
Column Internals for Deentrainment and Distribution Used Extensively All Very High
Centrifugally Aided Devices High Potential All High
Enhanced Heat-Transfer Surfaces Used Extensively All Very High
Columns in Motion on Ships and Floating Plants Used Gas High
Column Scanning Used Extensively All Very High
Model-Based Risk Analysis and Monitoring High Potential All Very High

Innovations in related fields such as fluid flow have also played a role in advancing distillation. For example, computational fluid dynamics (CFD) is now used extensively to design and troubleshoot distillation columns.

The need for continued innovation in the field is palpable. Even small improvements in distillation capacity, efficiency, availability, and cost will have a major impact. While innovations in the field have continued, the pace could stand to increase via more academic and government support. This article discusses distillation advancements and looks to new avenues to further develop the technology.

Describing fouling and corrosion

Electrolyte thermodynamic and vapor-liquid-solid equilibria data and models have been used to describe fouling and corrosion in distillation systems (Figure 1). These models can be combined with conventional process simulators to determine the dew point and acidity of the first liquid droplets produced on metal surfaces of columns. These initial droplets are the most corrosive, and these models can predict their occurrence and concentration to help prevent corrosion and fouling.

images

Figure 1. Electrolyte modeling tools can be combined with process simulators to predict fouling and corrosion conditions in crude distillation towers. The photo shows a distillation valve tray with severe scaling and fouling. Image courtesy of Doug Bouck.

Tray technology

Market competition has driven the continuous improvement of tray technology. Innovations are available from various equipment and technology suppliers that offer different versions of:

  • multiple-downcomer trays
  • minivalves (fixed and movable)
  • truncated-downcomer trays
  • push valves
  • non-chordal downcomers
  • small sieve holes
  • umbrella downcomers
  • dynamically sealed downcomers
  • fast-installation designs
  • fouling-resistant designs
  • centrifugal aids.

These improvements offer better performance at a reasonable cost without requiring complex fabrication. For example, truncated-downcomer trays increase vapor capacity because they provide more useable bubbling area. And, fouling-resistant designs keep distillation columns in service longer. Figure 2 is a centrifugally aided, high-capacity tray that is used in many retrofits. This tray employs centrifugal separators in the bubbling area to remove capacity limits caused by liquid entrainment (or jet flood).

images

Figure 2. The Shell ConSep tray is a centrifugally aided, high-capacity tray that is used mainly in tower retrofits. Photo courtesy of Shell.

Liquid distribution in packed towers

One of the most important realizations of the past 30 years is the massive effect that liquid and vapor distribution (or maldistribution) can have on the performance of packed distillation towers. Packings work in conjunction with distributors to evenly distribute liquid and vapor throughout the column. Much of the knowledge about liquid distribution is empirical, but there is room for more fundamental understanding of:

  • the hydraulics of gravity and pressurized distributors
  • the hydraulic behavior of packings in response to initial (poor or good) distribution
  • the application of phase distribution to mass-transfer models by assessing liquid-vapor variability in three dimensions.

Tools have been developed to assess the quality of phase distribution in a column in real time. Figure 3 presents the results of a gamma scan taken during column operation. Gamma scans map the density of the system at any given point to provide a snapshot of the amount of liquid and gas present in the voids.

images

Figure 3. ThruVision is a technique that provides a two-dimensional density profile of a cross-section of a tower that can be used to assess liquid distribution in packed sections. The horizontal axis shows the departure from the center of the column, and the vertical axis shows radiation intensity received by the detector, which correlates directly with density. Figure courtesy of Tracerco.

Feed devices, vapor and liquid distributors (Figure 4 and Figure 5), and packings (Figure 6) ensure even distribution throughout a column. The advanced vapor distributor in Figure 4 is suitable for feeds that contain vapor and liquid — the design allows for good vapor distribution, clean liquid disengagement, and minimal pressure drop.

images

Figure 4. Schoepentoeter-Plus is an advanced centrifugal device for deentrainment and vapor distribution commonly used for two-phase feeds into distillation columns. Figure courtesy of Sulzer Chemtech.

images

Figure 5. This modern liquid distributor (shown here on a stand for testing) increases column efficiency. Photo courtesy of Montz.

images

Figure 6. FLEXIPAC HC (left) is a high-capacity structured packing and Intalox Ultra (right) is a high-capacity random packing. These designs attempt to enhance aerodynamics to reduce drag resistance in all directions of flow. Photos courtesy of Koch-Glitsch.

Rate-based simulation

Rate-based models are used to describe distillation processes. Their widespread use creates opportunities to include more-fundamental and generalized mass-transfer and hydraulic models in simulations. This approach will create simulations that allow better interpolations and extrapolations from data for designing or analyzing systems. The rate-based approach lends itself to the use of less-empirical and more-general models to describe hardware performance.

This approach is of particular value in the area of chemically enhanced absorption, in which proper management of chemistry, hydraulics, and mass-transfer concepts makes solvents for reactive gases more effective. Models that effectively describe variables such as the physical chemistry of a system, liquid residence time, and interfacial area help to produce better designs. The current interest in carbon dioxide removal technologies will benefit from, and be of benefit to, advances in distillation technology; the more-rigorous models and efficient hardware developed for carbon capture will find a direct application in distillation.

Enhanced heat transfer in boiling and condensing systems

The performance of distillation systems is inextricably linked to the performance of associated heat-transfer equipment, such as reboilers and condensers. Research into shell-and-tube heat exchangers has helped to increase heat flux, enabling older units to be retrofitted with new tubes that increase performance with less capital expenditure.

These improvements have been rightly focused on addressing the larger resistances to heat transfer in boiling or condensing units (Figure 7). Since heat-transfer rates in boiling/condensing regimes are much higher, the improvements generally address the convective side of the heat-transfer process.

images

Figure 7. Enhancements to the design and texturing of reboiler and condenser tubes (HighFlux or HighCond) significantly improve heat-transfer rates by reducing the resistance on the convective side and improving the management of surface temperatures. Photo courtesy of UOP.

Enhanced distillation

Progress in thermodynamic understanding, column configurations, and column internals has helped to develop enhanced distillation processes, including:

  • extractive distillation for use with higher-boiling-point solvents
  • reactive distillation, which adds a reactant and/or catalyst to cause a reversible and selective reaction with one of the feed components
  • homogeneous azeotropic distillation, which includes an entrainer to form a minimum- or maximum-boiling-point azeotrope with one or more of the feed compounds
  • heterogeneous azeotropic distillation, which uses an entrainer to form a minimum-boiling-point heterogeneous azeotrope
  • pressure-swing distillation for pressure-sensitive azeotropes and at distillation boundaries
  • steam distillation, which adds steam to reduce the temperature of the distilling organic mixture
  • salt distillation, which dissolves a soluble ionic salt into the reflux to alter the relative volatilities of the feed.

The actual configuration of a distillation column affects its efficiency and impacts its size and capital requirements. Configurations that integrate the traditional function of two distillation columns in series into one single shell can offer savings in capital and energy, such as dividing-wall columns (DWCs) (Figure 8).

images

Figure 8. A dividing-wall column (DWC) is a self-heat-integrated column that saves energy and capital, and is ideal for three-component separations. This DWC is used to separate C5s, C6s, and C7s.

Need for development

While distillation has come a long way, the field needs to continue to advance. Progress would be welcome in areas such as modeling and simulation, improved reliability, improved capacity and efficiency, diagnostic tools, and hybrid processes that combine distillation with other separation techniques.

However, undoubtedly there will be advances in the field that we do not see coming. This is particularly true in the area of diagnostics and data acquisition and use. Our abilities in these areas are growing rapidly and their application to distillation is yet to be fully realized.

Distillation processes could play a significant role in carbon dioxide management, enabling separation and concentration of CO2 for sequestration and reuse.

Where the carbon dioxide content in natural gas is above 20%, distillation could be used to cryogenically separate CO2 from H2S and natural gas. In these cases, the traditional amine sweetening process becomes very large and expensive. A hybrid process that combines cryogenic distillation with CO2 freezing could lower capital requirements. A combination of distillation and membrane permeation may also prove to be cost-effective in these applications.

Another area prime for development is distillation at higher forces of gravity, such as cyclonic centrifugal action, which provides intimate contact between vapor and liquid but also aids in their subsequent disengagement. While there has been progress in this area, improved management of entrainment could help to push the fairly new field forward. This area requires further development of tools like CFD models and the actual hardware.

Other distillation configurations and hardware concepts have proven useful in the lab, but encounter significant hurdles at larger scales, including short-path distillation for heat-sensitive materials and microchannel distillation for performance improvement at close to minimum reflux.

Distillation is extremely effective at large scales, so displacing it from industrial use is rarely a successful economic endeavor. Nevertheless, alternatives to distillation exist in some instances, even at larger and medium scales, such as the use of adsorption processes for medium-scale gas separations and reverse osmosis membranes for water purification.

Emphasis in academia

The focus in chemical engineering education has steadily drifted away from traditional process engineering toward materials, bioengineering, drug delivery, nanotechnology, and other areas of interest. Due to government funding in these latter areas, chemical engineering educators have little professional exposure to traditional process engineering. While these new areas of research are exciting and promising, the oil and gas and chemical industries still need capable people to help reach industry goals, including those related to sustainability efforts.

Academic research could play a big role in advancing distillation technologies. Three areas of interest might be:

  • The incorporation of shear forces into CFD modeling to properly model entrainment and two-phase flow. This will aid the development of more-effective distillation internals.
  • A complete database and models for efficiencies of various systems measured in standardized Oldershaw (packed and trayed) equipment. This database would include effects of relative volatility, viscosity, density difference, surface tension, etc., as well as data at high pressure and vacuum. The database could also include comparisons of standardized test systems to large-scale data.
  • Creation of a rigorous model of the phase distribution, maldistribution, and redistribution in packed distillation towers. The hydraulic response of packings to various distribution conditions needs quantification and predictive modeling based on packing geometries. This hydraulic model could then be integrated into column simulation (staged or rate-based) to assess the true column efficiency.

A learning culture

The field of distillation could take a cue from the effective knowledge management of safety professionals in the CPI. On the one hand, the field has made progress, implementing new technologies effectively and continuously improving distillation design. But, on the other hand, the field continues to make the same mistakes over and over again in regard to design, installation, and operation. Many have made brilliant careers troubleshooting distillation problems, and they will tell you firsthand that most failures are ones that they continue to see.

For example, during the startup of refineries, it is common for water to inadvertently spill into a column containing hot hydrocarbons and create a violent rush of steam that damages internals. Poorly designed inlets for two-phase flow, improperly managed liquid levels, and other issues continue to plague the industry. Solving these recalcitrant problems is a matter of training, but organizations need to become learning organizations with effective knowledge management.

Closing thoughts

Opportunities to energize the R&D aspects of distillation in process engineering are plentiful, only requiring the attention of academia and industry to help realize the potential. Professionals and academics already working in this focus area should lead the charge to help secure funding for distillation R&D.

1

images

Author Bios: 

José L. Bravo

José L. Bravo is the President of Fractionation Research, Inc., a multi-client consortium that provides research and development services related to separations technologies. He is also a senior consultant to various clients in the areas of leadership, business and technology strategy, new technology development, innovation and research, and process and chemical engineering. Before joining FRI, he spent 22 years at Shell, in both the U.S. and Europe. His last role with the company was as Chief Scientist, advising the company’s leadership on innovation and technology strategy, as well as...Read more

Copyright Permissions: 

Would you like to reuse content from CEP Magazine? It’s easy to request permission to reuse content. Simply click here to connect instantly to licensing services, where you can choose from a list of options regarding how you would like to reuse the desired content and complete the transaction.