Patent Update: When Patent Enforcement Becomes Explotation


Patents are intended to promote and reward advances in technology, but they can also be a nuisance to both startups and established companies if the patent owner uses the threat of burdensome litigation to coerce companies into paying licensing fees. The case of Shipping & Transit LLC v. Hall Enterprises, Inc., demonstrates how a patent owner can generate considerable revenue using this strategy, yet be called to task for doing so.

Shipping & Transit sued Hall Enterprises for infringement of Shipping & Transit’s U.S. Patent Nos. 6,415,207, 6,763,299, and 6,904,359, which all relate to the monitoring and reporting of the location of a vehicle that is headed toward a series of destinations. The broadest of the claims that Shipping & Transit accused Hall of infringing recites the method of storing the locations of the destinations; monitoring the location of the vehicle relative to each destination; and selecting a second destination as the vehicle approaches the first destination, determining how long it will take the vehicle to reach the second destination, and notifying a party at the second destination of the expected arrival time. The trial court evaluated each step against the legal standards for patent-eligible subject matter, and the court found them all to be abstract ideas, i.e.,...

Author Bios: 

M. Henry Heines

M. Henry Heines, PhD, JD, (Email:; Website: is a patent attorney and an author, speaker, and consultant on patent-related topics for lawyers, as well as for scientists, engineers, and managers in technology companies, and has served as an expert witness in patent litigation. He began his career as a research engineer in the chemicals industry and worked in corporate patent practice before entering private practice, including 25 years as a partner in the firm now...Read more

Would you like to access the complete CEP Article?

No problem. You just have to complete the following steps.

You have completed 0 of 2 steps.

  1. Log in

    You must be logged in to view this content. Log in now.

  2. AIChE Membership

    You must be an AIChE member to view this article. Join now.

Copyright Permissions: 

Would you like to reuse content from CEP Magazine? It’s easy to request permission to reuse content. Simply click here to connect instantly to licensing services, where you can choose from a list of options regarding how you would like to reuse the desired content and complete the transaction.