(245b) Multiple-Particle Tracking Using the Birmingham Positron Camera

Fryer, P. J. - Presenter, University of Birmingham
Yang, Z. - Presenter, University of Birmingham
Bakalis, S. - Presenter, University of Birmingham
Parker, D. J. - Presenter, University of Birmingham
Fan, X. - Presenter, University of Birmingham
Seville, J. P. - Presenter, University of Warwick

The technique of positron emission particle tracking (PEPT) has been developed at the University of Birmingham for tracking a single particle accurately and non-invasively for various applications in engineering and science. The technique involves a positron camera, a labelled tracer particle and a location algorithm used for calculating the tracer location and speed. The camera consists of two position-sensitive detectors, each with an active area of 500x400 mm2, mounted on either side of the field of view, and is used to detect pairs of 511 keV g -rays. The tracer particle is labelled with a radionuclide which decays by b+ decay with the emission of a positron. Each positron rapidly annihilates with an electron, giving rise to a pair of 511 keV g -rays which are emitted almost exactly back-to-back. The two g -rays are simultaneously detected in the two detectors and define a trajectory passing close to the source. From a small number of detected trajectories, the tracer location can be determined using the location algorithm (Parker et al., 1993). From successive locations, the velocity of the labelled particle can be found as it passes through the view of the camera (Parker et al., 1996, 1997, 2002). The g -rays can penetrate considerable thickness of material so that PEPT has great advantages for providing insight into flow and mixing processes inside real plant without disturbing the process. For the past 20 years, the PEPT technique has been used to study a wide range of engineering processes by a number of research groups. The major drawback of the technique is that it is only capable of following a single tracer at any one time. There are a number of situations where it would be valuable to track both the position and rotation of a particle within a process. This requires tracking more than one tracer at once. For example in the food industry a number of processes involve the heating and cooling of solid-liquid mixtures, and the heat transfer coefficient between solid and liquid is critical (Mankad and Fryer, 1997; Mankad et al., 1997). To do this, rotational as well as translational behaviour needs to be known. Other applications include reactor engineering (Fishwick et al., 2003) and hydraulic conveying validation of leading-edge Discrete Element Methods (DEM).

In this paper, multiple-particle tracking, a new method that enables us to track more than one particle, is presented. Thus, to track multiple particles, the tracers are labelled with different radioactive levels, so that the number of g -rays received from each tracer is significantly different. The most active tracer can be located while the trajectories from the remaining tracers are regarded as corrupt trajectories. The location of the strongest tracer is the point which minimises the sum of perpendicular distances to the various trajectories. This procedure is iterative, in that, having calculated the minimum distance point for a set of trajectories as a first approximation, those passing furthest away are discarded and the minimum distance point recalculated using the remaining subset. The iteration procedure continues until it is believed that all corrupt trajectories have been discarded. Trajectories passing close to the located tracer are then removed from the dataset. The location of the second tracer is then calculated supposing that the trajectories from the third strongest tracer are corrupted. The location of the third tracer is calculated similarly.

Three typical examples are presented in this paper, one for tracking two stationary particles, one for tracking three stationary particles, and another for tracking three moving particles.

For two stationary particles, tracers were fixed on a metal stick on which the separation distance of particles could be adjusted. The stick was mounted approximately at the centre of the field of view of the detectors for each of the 72 runs. The separation distance of particles was varied over the range from 1.5mm to 13mm. The technique was validated by comparison of the distance obtained from PEPT measurements to the actual one. As the separation distance increased, the error decreased. Even when the separation distance is down to 3mm, the tracked distance error is only ± 0.7mm.

For testing three stationary particles, 12 tests have been performed. Three tracers were fixed at the corners of each of a set of wooden cubes which had different dimensions and were mounted in turn approximately at the centre of the field of view of the detectors. The dimension of the cubes varied from 5mm to 20mm. For each cube, the location algorithm was used to determine repeated sets of locations for the three tracers, and the consistency was determined by calculating the standard deviations within each set. The results show that the variations are reasonable. For example, the variations are 1.1mm and 1.6mm when the separation distances between three tracers are 28 mm and 7 mm respectively.

For moving particles, nine experiments have been taken with three tracers fixed on a cube having a dimension of 17 mm. The cube was mounted on a turntable rotating at constant speeds. The cube speeds varied from 3.5mm/s to 240mm/s. From the trajectories of the tracers, calculated by the multiple-particle tracking techniques, the three dimensional images of the cube can be reconstructed at any time, giving the rotational information of the cube. The latter, is an invaluable for understanding the relative movement of solids in various industrial applications. The results show that the errors of location and speed are acceptable. The r.m.s. location errors are only 1.8mm and 6mm, and the r. m. s. speed errors are 2mm/s and 25mm/s when the tracer speeds are 3.5mm/s and 240mm/s respectively.

Once the technique was validated three non restricted tracers were placed in a 150 mm fluidized bed filled with 500 mm glass beads. Parameters such as occupancy and tracer velocity vectors, circulation times were used. The results indicated that there was no apparent difference between the data obtained from different tracers.

The multiple-particle tracking technique has shown that it can not only track positions of particles but also provides the rotation information of solids with any regular shapes. The examples have been shown to give valuable and accurate results for stationary and moving particles rotating at speeds up to 240mm/s which are relevant to many industrial applications. The procedure is relatively simple and can be implemented for fundamental research as well as industrial applications.


This paper has an Extended Abstract file available; you must purchase the conference proceedings to access it.


Do you already own this?



AIChE Members $150.00
AIChE Graduate Student Members Free
AIChE Undergraduate Student Members Free
Non-Members $225.00